Background and Purpose
Patella Tendinopathy is a chronic condition of the patella tendon, which can affect athletes of all ages who partake in sport, particularly in activities that involve high impact movements or stop start actions.(Leite et al., 2015; López-Royo et al., 2020; Rodriquez-Merchan, 2012; Schwartz et al., 2015) The patella tendon can be disrupted in both the central portion and para-tendon, where repeated stress and load effect the collagen proteins within the tendon leading to pain and reduced function.(Andres & Murrele, 2008; Cook & Khan, 2001; El-Khoury et al., 1992) Insertional and mid tendon irritation can occur within the structure and present with similar symptoms that require comparable treatment.(Aicale et al., 2020; Leibbrandt & Louw, 2017; Simpson & Smith, 2013) Within elite sport, acute and chronic forms of patella tendinopathy are seen where athletes are subject to spikes and changes in load.(Malliaras et al., 2013; Silbernagel et al., 2019) Due to the variability of sport and the constant adaptation of load to suit fixtures and opposition, the management and treatment of patella tendinopathy is wide and varied. The change in environments and need to maintain high training load make management challenging with acute and long-term strategies available in both manual and passive treatments.
The present case study presents a 24 yrs old championship footballer with chronic patella tendinopathy. Symptoms have existed for 3-4yrs, with increases in the volume of training (load) being a key aggravating factor, i.e. return to pre-season training. The injury was initially diagnosed 4yrs ago utilising Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI).(Cook & Khan, 2001; Malliaras et al., 2013; Pizzolato et al., 2019) The player returned late to pre-season during the 2019/2020 season (week 3) and was utilised in two games playing 45 minutes (mins) in each game, separated by 48 hours (hrs). This represented an acute spike in training load(Blanch & Gabbett, 2016) and replicated a period of fixture congestion where the athlete may not have adequately recovered between games.(Rhodes et al., 2018, 2020) Post-game 2, match day +1 (MD+1), the player reported 8/10 pain (visual analogue scale (VAS)) within his knee. Attempting to train he was unable to perform high velocity movements and was withdrawn from training.
Immediate assessment by the Physiotherapist identified left insertional tendon pain during a single leg squat and squat jump. Focal pain was noted at the infra apex of the patella and proximal patella tendon, with reduction in knee flexion and passive extension due to pain. Insertional tendinopathy was proposed with potential fat pad involvement as a diagnosis. MRI was completed 24 hrs post assessment, which revealed a normal distal patella tendon with thickening within the central tendon into the proximal attachment measuring 7.4 mm in length. A prominent inferior patella pole was noted but no calcification found. The MRI report suggested a partial interstitial tear of the central tendon which was reviewed by a consultant immediately via Ultrasound Scan (USS) to confirm no tear but aggravated proximal patella tendinopathy. Conservative management was highlighted as the most appropriate method of treatment and only if this was unsuccessful surgery was to be explored. A carefully designed rehabilitation programme was developed and implemented (Table 1).
This case study describes the successful return to sport of a 24 yr old Championship footballer through the conservative management and rehabilitation of chronic insertional patella tendinopathy. Previous research and literature has shown that patella tendinopathy has been managed with rest, offload from aggravating factors and heavy eccentric exercise to load and stress the collagen within the tendon matrix.(Alfredson, 2011; Kamen, 1985; Malliaras et al., 2013; Pizzolato et al., 2019; Visnes & Bahr, 2007) This loading incorporates a high load with a high number of repetitions to cause maximum stress to the area, often resulting in fatigue and increase in symptoms for 24-hrs.(Andres & Murrele, 2008; Cook & Khan, 2001; Schwartz et al., 2015; Simpson & Smith, 2013) This technique has proved successful, but results can take 8 weeks of consistent management before symptoms change and adaptation noted.(Cook & Khan, 2001; Leibbrandt & Louw, 2017) Implementation of an isometric strength focussed conservative rehabilitation programme returned the current case study to light training at day 21, full training day 24 and playing competitively at day 30. Completion of a 6-month post RTP review highlighted that the player was still asymptomatic with no associated patella tendon pain. Although, it must be noted that the players training load was continually monitored and he was not exposed to more than two consecutive days of functional training or game play.
Conservative management within the present case study focussed on the early introduction of isometric strengthening. Isometric loading of the patella tendon has recently been proposed as more effective for pain management and restoration of strength.(Bianco et al., 2019; Malliaras et al., 2013; Pizzolato et al., 2019) Loading in this manner shows a significant reduction in tendon pain during rehabilitation and allows loading to increase quickly without accumulative fatigue.(Golman et al., 2020; Rio et al., 2015; Van Ark et al., 2016) This early reduction in pain is vital in maintaining a steady 24-hr pattern and allowing progressive loading such as isotonic and heavy slow exercises.(Rio et al., 2015) Isolated isometric quadricep strengthening was implemented throughout the rehabilitation of the presented athlete and began day 1. Due to the longevity of the players condition and the initial VAS scale presentation of 8/10, pain was utilised as a key marker of player progression and gradual increase of training load. It was agreed with the player, with guidance from a specialist within the area, that pain must remain stable throughout rehabilitation. Stable pain was agreed as 5/10 VAS lasting no more than 24 hrs post exercise. Table 1 indicates the players VAS score throughout rehabilitation, with pain always remaining stable. Although, it is important to note increases in the players pain between days 9 - 11, which coincided with the introduction of heavy slow metronome work, representing more functional contraction through the musculature.
Evidence indicates that patella tendinopathy patients have high cortical inhibition of the quadricep muscle groups, and that heavy isometric loading causes a decrease in this substance within the tendon.(Rio et al., 2015) Isometric loading is positive for patella tendinopathy but should not be the sole exercise applied for effective management and pain control.(Cook & Khan, 2001) The current case study utilised a combination of isometric, isotonic and heavy slow patterns to produce improved strength, greater pain relief and a successful return to full function.(Van Ark et al., 2016) It is important to note that more functional strengthening work, whether closed or open chain, was only introduced when stable pain was reported by the athlete. Consideration was given to basic training principles in the rehabilitation design, most notably frequency and overload particularly in the earlier stages of isometric loading. Literature highlights that regular loading should be the foundation of any rehabilitation programme involving tendons, with short rest periods which stimulate the tendon and ensure matrix formations and collagen alignment is linear.(Pizzolato et al., 2019; Van Ark et al., 2016) Careful consideration should also be given for rest between sets and longer total rest between sessions. Rest periods above 90 seconds between sets highlight no improvement in performance or pain control and longer rest between sessions show no collagen change within the tendon when compared to short rest periods and consistent daily loading.(Waugh et al., 2018) Advocating the approach taken within the present case study.
Progressive loading from isometric to eccentric strength work without exacerbating the patients pain has been shown to be more successful in the treatment and management of patella tendinopathy, without the addition of other manual therapy techniques.(Andres & Murrell, 2008; Leite et al., 2015; López-Royo et al., 2020; Rio et al., 2015) This was successfully demonstrated within the present case study. Due to the complex nature of elite athletes however, holistic approaches should not be discounted(Foell, 2010) and other modalities can be utilised to facilitate the rehabilitation process. Aetiological research associated with patella tendinopathy emphasises its multi factorial nature. The present study implemented the use of 15g gelatine with 200mg vitamin C consumed 60 mins before loading. Evidence suggests that this added supplementation facilitates tissue repair by increasing amino acid levels within the blood, with no side effects noted.(Baar, 2017; Shaw et al., 2017) In addition to this to modulate pain and enhance function, glyceryl trinitrate (GTN) patches were utilised.(López-Royo et al., 2020; Paolini, 2006; Rodriguez-Merchan, 2013) GTN patches consistently used within the patient’s tolerance levels with a structured rehabilitation programme have exhibited very good patient outcomes within tendinopathy cases.(Challoumas et al., 2019) Research also highlights that GTN use in chronic conditions has resulted in increased tendon strength.(Paolini, 2006; Williamson, 2011) Careful consideration of their use must be given however, due to the side effects experienced, which can include severe headaches and skin rashes.(Challoumas et al., 2019; Williamson, 2011) Predominantly research indicates only good outcomes when utilised for 24 weeks+.(Steunebrink et al., 2013; Zwerver et al., 2013) Time pressures associated with returning athletes quickly and safely would not advocate its use. Although successfully implemented within the current case study further research is required to support its use within an elite setting and its successful use in this case study may be the result of a placebo effect.
Successful management of this injury was facilitated by completing a full subjective and objective assessment with markers obtained to control and manage the athlete’s symptoms. Imaging was incorporated within the diagnosis of the condition and to identify the specific area of concern. A rounded loading approach was applied with isometric and isotonic drills prescribed before progression to energy release and pitch-based training. Medical and conditioning based specialists could apply these techniques with confidence in their effect and success on patella tendinopathy and structured return to play in a safe and controlled manner.
CONFLICT OF INTEREST
The authors declare that there are no conflicts of interest.
No funding was received for this work.